Events and Insights Gleaned from the Minneapolis Crisis

In a time where public debates are often fuelled by emotive rhetoric, evolutionary biologist Colin Wright, a fellow at the Manhattan Institute, has raised concerns about ideologies that distort reality. These ideologies, he argues, are particularly prevalent in discussions surrounding sex, suicide, medical treatment, and threats to people's safety.

Wright's concerns are not unfounded. Activists have been known to weaponize distorted numbers, creating an atmosphere of fear and impending doom that can be detrimental to those who are already vulnerable and unstable. This approach can convince individuals that they are on the verge of annihilation, a mindset that Wright warns against, as it only entrenches the sense of an impending existential threat.

One area where this distortion of facts is particularly prevalent is in the discussion around trans-identifying individuals and the suicide rate among this group. While it is often claimed that the suicide rate is significantly higher among trans-identifying people to justify medical procedures, systematic reviews have found a lack of clear evidence supporting the benefits of these treatments.

Wright's argument is not about denying the existence of suffering within the trans community, but rather about the need to be honest about the evidence for "gender-affirming care." He advocates for affirming the biological reality of sex, rejecting inflated and manipulative claims about suicide, and resisting the use of suffering people as political pawns.

The tragic shooting at Annunciation Catholic School in Minneapolis serves as a stark reminder of the potential consequences of such ideologies. While Colin Wright is not responsible for the actions of the shooter, Robin Westman, he does emphasize the need for truth and transparency to prevent such tragedies from occurring.

In the United States, there has been no credible organisation in recent years advocating for armed conflicts against the transgender community. Opposition groups often express their views through political or ideological means, not calls for armed violence. However, it is important to note that extremist or hate groups may indirectly promote hostility.

Journalist Andy Ngo has documented the rise of pro-trans groups that openly promote armed resistance. Meanwhile, activist groups have popularized the false claim that Republicans are committing a trans "genocide."

Wright's argument is not about stigmatising or marginalising the trans community, but about the need to tell the truth to avoid more tragedies caused by ideologies that deny reality. He urges us to resist the use of suffering people as political pawns and to work towards a society where everyone is treated with respect and dignity.

The photo accompanying this article is by Scott Olson/Getty Images.

In a separate incident, Robin Westman, a former student, opened fire at Annunciation Catholic School, resulting in the murder of two children and injuries to many others. Robin Westman identified as a woman, but it is suggested that he was profoundly disturbed and that mental illness preceded his transgender identity. Westman left behind a manifesto and notes on his weapons containing violent fantasies, political rage, and admiration for other mass murderers.

This tragedy underscores the importance of Wright's arguments. Trans identification is often described as a coping mechanism for underlying distress rather than its root cause. By perpetuating the idea that society is conspiring to wipe out a generation of distressed youth, we create a powder keg that can lead to devastating consequences.

In conclusion, it is crucial to approach discussions about trans-identifying individuals with truth, empathy, and a commitment to understanding the complexities of mental health and identity. By doing so, we can work towards a society where everyone is treated with the respect and dignity they deserve.