Skip to content

Politicians toiled to draft balanced electoral boundaries. What are their sentiments after Newsom annuls them?

California's Citizens Redistricting Commission, established by voters to curb political manipulation, finds itself split over Democrats' redistricting maneuver. Yet, they uniformly express pride in their accomplishments.

Politicians labored to create balanced electoral districts. What are their sentiments now that...
Politicians labored to create balanced electoral districts. What are their sentiments now that Newsom is nullifying those maps?

Politicians toiled to draft balanced electoral boundaries. What are their sentiments after Newsom annuls them?

The California Citizens Redistricting Commission, a body established in 2008 to bring balance to legislative races, has been in existence since its creation. Over the past decade, the commission, consisting of 14 diverse individuals from different backgrounds, spent over a year plotting out the state's political boundaries, producing 176 maps over the course of 16 months.

In 2010, voters extended the commission's oversight to congressional races. The members of this commission, who went through a grueling selection process overseen by the nonpartisan state auditor, worked for free, receiving no salary, but did get a $378 per diem on days they spent in session.

One of the commissioners, Patricia Sinay, a Democrat who served on the commission, has expressed uncertainty about Proposition 50 and wants reassurance that congressional redistricting will revert to the commission after the next census. Sinay stated that she will support "whatever the people of California want".

Another commissioner, Trena Turner, a pastor in Stockton and fellow Democrat, believes the impartial approach to political line-drawing by the California Citizens Redistricting Commission should be a model for the rest of America. On the other hand, Russell Yee, a Republican commissioner, is generally opposed to the Democratic gerrymandering effort.

The work of the California Citizens Redistricting Commission may come undone due to a proposed partisan redistricting that could wipe out California's Republican representation in Congress. This redistricting reform, supported by California Gov. Gavin Newsom, could overturn the existing congressional gerrymandering and potentially give Democrats an advantage.

Notably, no one sued to overturn the commission's work, a rarity in the highly litigious field of redistricting. Sara Sadhwani, a Democrat who teaches political science at Pomona College, spoke at Gov. Newsom's rally kicking off the gerrymandering effort and testified before the state Senate, urging lawmakers to put the matter before voters.

Neal Fornaciari, a Republican who chairs the redistricting commission, stated that the commission is in no way involved in the current redistricting effort. The person supporting the initiative for a vote on the redistricting in California is Governor Gavin Newsom. He has announced a special election on November 4th for citizens to decide on this redistricting reform.

The California Citizens Redistricting Commission was created in 2008 when California voters approved Proposition 11, also known as the Voters First Act, to take redistricting away from lawmakers. More than 30,000 Californians applied for the positions on the commission, demonstrating the public's interest in fair and impartial redistricting.

As the November 4th vote approaches, the future of the California Citizens Redistricting Commission and the state's political landscape hangs in the balance.

Read also: